Crock Pot Apple Butter

My son and I love apple butter. I was raised eating it on toast and biscuits and I love it so much I can eat it by the spoonful. I was really surprised to find out that not everyone knows what apple butter is.

Boyfriend: “It’s apples and butter, right?”

Me: “Nooooo…There’s no butter in apple butter!”

Boyfriend: “Then why is it called apple BUTTER?”

Heck if I know,why is a driveway called a driveway when you just park on it? If anyone has the answers, please enlighten me.

It must be a Kentucky thing, says my boyfriend!

Since fall is getting ready to start and it’s apple season (not to mention my grandmother gave me 21 pounds of apples when she found out I was thinking about making apple butter) I decided to try my hand at homemade apple butter. I scoured the internet looking for interesting, but easy, recipes and found one on A Year of Slow Cooking. I cut out some of the sugar after reading about how sweet the apple butter turned out and since I’m somewhat health conscious, I figured we didn’t need all that sugar anyway. It turned out just yummy and my boyfriend has now been educated on all things apple butter!

This is cooked completely in the crock pot and takes a day and a half to two days to cook. apple butter canned


Apples (I used about 8 lbs of small to medium Washington apples)

1 Tablespoon Vanilla

2 teaspoons Cinnamon

1/2 teaspoon ground cloves

1 cup brown sugar

1/4 cup white sugar


I peeled all the apples first because I didn’t want to pick out the peels after the apples cooked. Believe me, this extra step is worth it.

Core and quarter the apples and place in crock pot.

cut apples

Add vanilla. Cover and cook on low for 8 hrs.

After 8 hrs, mash the apples. I used a potato masher. At this point they are almost mush anyway so this was pretty easy. If you didn’t peel the apples now is the time to pick out all the peels.

mashed apples

Add cinnamon, cloves and sugar and stir.

Cover and cook on low for additional 6 hrs.

Once the apple butter is done, blend with a stick blender (or Immersion blender, if you want to use the fancy name for it). Be careful, it is hot and it will splatter on you, speaking from experience!

That’s it…delish!

finsished apple butter

Now over the hills and through the woods to grandma’s house I go to get her to help me can all of this apple butter!